Your Eating Disorder Questions, Answered.
Submit your questions about eating disorders, available treatments, research, resources, or whatever is on your mind. Questions are answered by our staff eating disorder experts.
Please submit your questions to christinemknorr@gmail.com with "ED Question" in the subject line. Your question may be changed slightly to protect your confidentiality. Your name, location, email address, or other personal information will not be posted or shared.
Looking to schedule a session or have questions about starting therapy with us? Visit this page
You can find answers to questions about insurance & fees here, and answers to general questions about Christine Knorr Psychotherapy Associates here.
Questions about Treatment & Recovery
Do I need to see an eating disorder specialist?
Can I see my regular therapist and an eating disorder therapist at the same time?
Question: I have been seeing my therapist in [Rockland County town] for over a year now but I have not shared much about my eating disorder with her. When I started seeing her I was doing better with my anorexia but now I am starting to get worse lately. She has told me that she does not specialze but she can keep seeing me as long as my anorexia is not active. We get along great and I like her. She was a support to me through so many things and I am so grateful for her. Can I keep seeing her and see an eating disorder therapist at the same time?
Answered by Christine Knorr, LCSW CEDS
Your current therapist sounds wise and wonderful. You've recieved a lot of help from her, and you clearly have a good relationship. Like all good therapists, it sounds like she is aware of what she can best help you with, and what she should refer out to a specialist. This is similar to the way physicians work. Think of it this way: you would not want your Dermatologist to perform open-heart surgery, and you would not expect your Cardiologist to cure your acne. We specialize because some mental health concerns, like eating disorders, require specialized training and experience to be treated effectively.
Not all therapists are as wise as yours. Many therapists will attempt to work with someone who has an eating disorder, even though they've had very little specialized training and are not really qualified to do so. Best case scenario, the person does not improve, feels more confused than they were before they started therapy, and leaves therapy feeling like they can't be helped. Worst case scenario, the therapist does real harm, the eating disorder gets worse, or the eating disorder is left essentially untreated for a long period of time, which prolongs the person's suffering and solidifies the eating disorder thoughts and behaviors.
In the second part of your question, you asked whether you could continue to see your therapist while seeing another therapist who specializes in treating eating disorders. I don't recommend it, for two reasons. First, because it is not generally recommended for a person to see two therapists at the same time. It can be costly, for one thing. If you're using your insurance, they may not pay your provider or reimburse you for two services rendered within the same day or timeframe. It can also be counterproductive. You may recieve conflicting messages from each therapist or find that maintaining two therapeutic relationships feels overwhelming.
Second, it is not recommended to see your general therapist at the same time as an eating disorder therapist because it is simply not necessary. I say this as an eating disorder therapist of twenty years: when we treat an eating disorder, we are not just treating the eating disorder, we are treating everything. No one ever comes to me with "just" an eating disorder. People with eating disorders usually have multiple concerns: depression, anxiety, trauma, complicated family dynamics, etc. etc. etc. Some of it is part of the eating disorder, some of it existed before the eating disorder, and some of it is its own thing. It really depends on the person. In short, it is not possible to treat the eating disorder without also treating eveything underneath it and around it. To be an eating disorder therapist, you really have to be good at everything. That's why I say in several places on this website that "we treat the whole person, not just the eating disorder."
That being said, I'm hearing in your question that you like your current therapist and don't want to stop working with her. It is so hard to find a good therapist, I know. So how about this: talk it over with her. As difficult as it is, be as honest as you can be with her. If you want to, have her call me . The three of us can work out a clinically sound plan that will be best for you. It's not "all or nothing". We can work out a comfortable transition plan, or you can plan to meet with her for check-in sessions throughout our work together. And of course, when you are back on track with your eating disorder recovery, you can always return to her. Thank you for this very good question! I hope to hear from you again soon.
Questions From Parents
What are the levels of care in eating disorder treatment?
Question: We were told by the pediatrician that My daugher (15 years old) needs a higher level of care for her eating disorder. Currently she sees a therapist online through [large telehealth company} and we recently started with a nutritionist. I don't think my daughter needs to be in a hospital as she is at a stable weight for her height and the doctor agrees. What does "higher level of care" mean in this case?
Answered by Christine Knorr, LCSW CEDS
There are five levels of care in eating disorder treatment: inpatient, residential, partial hospitalization (PHP), intensive outpatient (IOP), and outpatient. Each level of care offers a different amount of support. The level of care your daughter needs depends on her medical status, symptom severity, history, and co-occurring disorders.
Here is a description of each level of eating disorder care, and a bit about what to expect from each one:
Inpatient: This is the highest level of care in eating disorder treatment, meaning that it provides the most support for people who have medical complications that cannot be safely managed in other settings. This type of care takes place in a hospital, and requires the person to be admitted overnight or longer. Some hospitals have a dedicated inpatient unit for eating disorders, while others do not. The goal of inpatient care for an eating disorder is to medically support and stabilize until it is safe for the person to be out of the hospital. If a person has been sent to the hospital or given the recommendation by a doctor to admit to the hospital, it would not be safe or appropriate for them to be at any other level of care. If you need inpatient care, there is not usually time to choose the hospital you like best. Usually, the hosptial closest to where you are now is the one that you need to go to, especially if it is urgent. However, if you have the rare luxury of having a little time to choose, you can give me a call and I can provide you with information on children's hospitals that have eating disorder inpatient units, medical transport for out of state hospitals, and hospitals that can accmmodate various needs.
Residential: This level of care is for people who are generally medically stable but require 24/7 support. Residential treatment centers usually provide basic medical care and monitoring, and some can accommodate more complex presentations. Most residential programs take place in a home-like setting that looks more like a house or dorm than a hospital. While people are in Residential, they stay there for a few weeks or months. While they are there, they participate in individual therapy, group therapy, family therapy, and nutrition counseling. Family can visit regularly, especially parents of children and teens. Some programs also have things like outings in the community, holiday celebrations, art therapy, and other things that make staying there feel a bit more pleasant. While a person is in residental treatment, they will usually eat every meal and snack with staff and other patients. Most of the meals take place in a regular dining room, similar to home. Meals there are usually prepared by a chef or kitchen staff, and are planned by a nutritionist to meet the needs of each individual patient. Most residential programs accept insurance, and most will work with you to verify your insurance and explain your benefits to you. There are residential eating disorder facilities in nearly every state, and several close by to Rockland County. Most residential programs are age-specific or gender-specific, and many have programs for specific populations or concerns.
Partial Hospitalization Program (PHP): Don't let the name fool you; this level of care has nothing to do with being in a hospital (not even partially). Think of it like going to work or school: PHP programs usually have a schedule similar to a work schedule (9am-5pm Monday through Friday), though schedules can vary. Some start earlier or later, and some meet on different days. You'll go to the program for most of the day, and then go home at night. PHP programs take place in a clinic-type setting. People usually attend PHP for a few weeks or months. The programming is similar to Residential: group therapy, individual therapy, family therapy, nutrition therapy. Participants generally eat two meals per day there, with one meal being on your own at home. PHP programs may provide some medical monitoring, but you'll need to see your physician regularly. Most PHP programs have separate cohorts or tracks for different ages, so if you're an adult you won't need to be in a group with teens, and vice versa.
Intensive Outpatient (IOP): This level of care is similar to PHP, but takes place fewer days per week and/or fewer hours per day. Most IOP programs are 3 days per week, and participants usually eat one meal there with the staff and other patients. IOP is a great option for someone who has completed PHP and is tapering down on how much support they need, or for people who need a bit more support than just once per week therapy.
Outpatient: This is just another name for regular therapy. Some therapists specialize in treating eating disorders, while many do not. All of the therapists at Christine Knorr Psychotherapy Associates are eating disorder specialists and have experience working in residential, PHP, and IOP settings.
In outpatient therapy, you'll see your therapist once per week. However, some people benefit from more support than that. Options for more support in outpatient include:
-
Seeing a Registered Dieititian/Nutritionist in addition to your therapist
-
Attending a support group between sessions with your therapist
-
Seeing your therapist twice a week instead of once a week, when needed
-
Meal support with a therapist or recovery coach
Many people attend therapy just once per week and do quite well with that plan. Every person's needs are different.
As far as answering your original question about your daughter: It is difficult for me to say what level of care she needs without more information. I am happy to meet with your daughter and do a comprehensive assessment that will provide you with a diagosis, treatment plan, and level of care recommendation. I can talk with you and your daughter about her needs, expectations, and worries, and help you to identify the specific program that will be right for her. Because we have worked in these programs and have colleagues who still do, we are familiar with the nuances of each treatment program, how they work and what they're like. We also visit the local programs to see them for ourselves and meet the staff. So my staff and I can help you figure out which program out of all the options will be right for your daughter and your family. We have direct phone numbers for representatives at each center and can put you in touch with them directly. I know it is scary to think about sending your daughter away to a program, and hopefully I can offer you some information and support that will make the whole thing a bit easier. Please feel free to give me a call at 845-505-1119 or message me to set up an assessment. Best of luck to you and your daughter, and hope to hear from you again soon.
Questions About How To Help A Loved One
Please submit your questions to christinemknorr@gmail.com with "ED Question" in the subject line. Your question may be changed slightly to protect your confidentiality. Your name, location, email address, or other personal information will not be posted or shared.
Questions From Professionals
Please submit your questions to christinemknorr@gmail.com with "ED Question" in the subject line. Your question may be changed slightly to protect your confidentiality. Your name, location, email address, or other personal information will not be posted or shared.
